Skip to main content

Table 1 Daily surgery demand prediction results (MAPE)

From: Daily surgery caseload prediction: towards improving operating theatre efficiency

 

Emergency surgery

Elective surgery

Overall surgery

1-year %

2-year %

3-year %

1-year %

2-year %

3-year %

1-year %

2-year %

3-year %

Rolling window

11.79

12.05

13.66

13.26

12.61

12.97

9.52

9.83

11.31

Regression (Linear)

N/A

13.71

13.79

N/A

17.79

15.84

N/A

13.49

12.85

Regression (Poisson)

N/A

14.17

14.71

N/A

18.90

16.68

N/A

13.99

13.77

Regression (Negative binomial)

N/A

14.13

14.88

N/A

19.12

16.67

N/A

14.08

13.86

Decision tree

15.69

17.97

18.30

14.55

13.91

14.72

15.99

13.97

12.14

Random forest

11.73

11.50

11.63

16.41

11.51

12.99

10.44

9.86

9.88

SVR (Linear)

19.13

16.50

17.50

15.61

15.62

15.19

35.81

37.93

36.96

SVR (RBF)

22.35

19.37

17.86

13.60

13.65

13.78

74.68

57.40

48.15

SVR (Sigmoid)

20.49

51.91

50.95

15.19

18.94

21.02

60.37

50.05

51.49

SVR (Poly)

44.12

26.67

23.63

19.23

21.31

15.55

90.15

48.84

36.43

Bagging regressor

12.86

11.97

12.50

13.62

11.90

14.25

10.62

10.42

10.26

Gradient boosting regressor

13.25

11.69

11.27

11.63

16.52

14.00

10.74

11.21

10.61

XGBoost regressor

13.60

13.65

14.89

37.18

15.74

40.92

15.06

11.64

11.22

Ensemble regressor

12.36

11.46

11.61

12.99

12.69

13.30

10.33

9.97

9.82

  1. The underlined values indicate the best performance in each column
  2. Boldfaced values refer to the overall best performance