Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 1 Number and type of users involved in the evaluation activities

From: What do healthcare professionals need to turn risk models for type 2 diabetes into usable computerized clinical decision support systems? Lessons learned from the MOSAIC project

  Number and gender Age Years of Experience Type of Expertise IT Literacy (Min 0, Max 3)
Design
 Clinical Focus Group Solution 1 M = 4;F = 1 57 ± 8 30 ± 7 MD = 2, HCM = 2, N/O = 1 H = 3;M = 1;L = 1
 Clinical Focus Group Solution 2 M = 5, F = 3 46 ± 14 17 ± 11 MD = 6, HCM = 1, GP = 1 H = 2;M = 3;L = 3
 Clinical Focus Group Solution 1 and 2 M = 1;F = 3 50 ± 8 23 ± 12 MD = 3, HCM = 1, N/O = 0 H = 2;M = 2;L = 0
 Scientific Focus Group M = 1;F = 3 55 ± 5 22 ± 5 MD = 2, HCM = 1, N/O = 1 H = 3;M = 1;L = 0
 Business Focus Group M = 13;F = 4 46 ± 10 19 ± 10 MD = 0, HCM = 17, N/O = 1 H = 17;M = 0;L = 0
 Analytic Hierarchy Process Solution 1 M = 2;F = 6 47 ± 9 20 ± 10 MD = 3, HCM = 3, N/O = 2 H = 1;M = 5;L = 0
 Analytic Hierarchy Process Solution 2.1 M = 3;F = 3 54 ± 9 29 ± 10 MD = 2, HCM = 1, N/O = 3 H = 2;M = 6;L = 0
 Analytic Hierarchy Process Solution 2.2 M = 2;F = 6 43 ± 12 17 ± 11 MD = 5, HCM = 3, N/O = 0 H = 0;M = 7;L = 1
Implementation
 Heuristic Evaluations (Solution 1 and 2) M = 2,F = 3 34 ± 4 8 ± 4 BE (4), GD (1), SWD (2) H = 5; M = 0;L = 0
 Usability Test Solution 1 M = 3, F = 1 46 ± 13 14 ± 6 MD = 2, HCM = 1, N/O = 1 H = 2; M = 1; L = 1
 Usability Test Solution 2 M = 1, F = 4 38 ± 10 13 ± 11 MD = 4, N/O = 1 H = 1; M = 3; L = 1
Evaluation
 Solution 1 M = 1, F = 6 42 ± 9 14 ± 10 MD = 6, HCM = 1, N/O = 0 H = 3; M = 3; L = 1
 Solution 2 M = 3, F = 6 41 ± 15 13 ± 12 MD = 6, HCM = 2, N/O = 1 H = 2; M = 5; L = 2
  1. M Male, F Female, BE Biomedical engineer, GD Graphic designer, SWD SoftWare developer, MD Medical doctor, HCM Health care manager, GP General practitioner, N/O Nurses or others; H High, M Medium, L Low