Skip to main content

Table 20 Findings of the replicated studies compared to our results

From: Replicating medication trend studies using ad hoc information extraction in a clinical data warehouse

 

Finding

Rep.

 

Main findings: The use of antidiabetic and antihypertensive medications generally followed treatment guideline recommendations:

 

1

The use of metformin was significantly limited with increasing CKD severity

Yes

2

The use of insulin increased sharply in severe CKD stages

Yes

3

Antihypertensive medications were used extensively

Yes

4

The level of RAAS inhibitor (including ACE inhibitors and ARBs) use was consistent, even in patients without CKD and with mild-to-moderate CKD

Yes

5

Use of thiazide diuretics was more prevalent than other diuretic agents with mild-to-moderate CKD

Yes

6

Thiazide diuretics were replaced by loop diuretics among those with moderate CKD to kidney failure

Yes

 

Other findings

 
 

Antidiabetes medications:

 

7

Overall, 83.1% of individuals with T2DM received antidiabetic medications

No

8

The use of insulin, biguanide (metformin), and sulfonylurea (SU) was significantly different between patients without CKD, those with mild-to-moderate CKD, and those with moderate CKD to kidney failure

Yes

9

The use of dipeptidyl peptidase-4 (DPP-4) inhibitors was similar

Yes

10

The use of sulfonylurea (SU)s increased in later CKD stages (3b and 4)

No

11

Sulfonylurea SU use dropped in CKD stage 5

Yes

 

Antihypertensive medications:

 

12

Overall, 75.7% of individuals with T2DM received antihypertensive medications

Yes

13

Use was extensive in those with CKD stage 2 or higher

Yes

14

Fewer than two-thirds were taking some form of RAAS inhibitor

(Yes)

15

There was a difference in the use of ACE inhibitors and ARBs between patients without CKD, those with mild-to-moderate CKD, and those with moderate CKD to kidney failure

Yes

16

The use of β-blockers, diuretics, and CCBs was statistically different

Yes

17

ARBs appeared to be more commonly used in stages 3a–4

Yes

18

The use of β-blocker and CCBs trended upward with increasing CKD severity

(Yes)

19

Diuretic use also increased from stage 1 through stage 4, but sharply fell in stage 5

Yes

20

Dhiazide diuretics were more commonly used by individuals without CKD or with mild-to-moderate CKD compared with other diuretic subclasses

Yes

21

In later CKD stages, the dominance of thiazide diuretics was replaced with loop diuretics

Yes

22

β-Blocker use increased with stages 4 and 5 CKD

No

  1. Study: Understanding CKD among patients with T2DM: prevalence, temporal trends, and treatment patterns—NHANES 2007–2012