Skip to main content

Table 8 The performance comparison of our SBLC model with the baseline methods on the same NCBI test dataset

From: SBLC: a hybrid model for disease named entity recognition based on semantic bidirectional LSTMs and conditional random fields

Methods

Precision

Recall

F1

Dictionary look-up [2]

0.213

0.718

0.316

cTAKES (version 4.0) [15]

0.476

0.541

0.506

MetaMap (semantic type filtering) [14]

0.495

0.679

0.541

MetaMap (MEDIC filtering) [14]

0.510

0.702

0.559

Inference method [2]

0.597

0.731

0.637

CRF + CMT [34]

0.795

0.683

0.735

CRF + MeSH [34]

0.855

0.660

0.746

CRF + UMLS [34]

0.839

0.688

0.756

DNorm [3]

0.822

0.775

0.798

C-Bi-LSTM-CRF [34]

0.848

0.761

0.802

TaggerOne [22]

0.835

0.796

0.815

TaggerOne(+ normalization) [22]

0.851

0.808

0.829

DNER [24]

0.853

0.833

0.843

SBLC

0.866

0.858

0.862

  1. The highest values are denoted in bold type