Skip to main content

Table 2 Patients’ preferences, congruence and direction of mismatch in medical decision-making

From: Congruence between patients’ preferred and perceived participation in medical decision-making: a review of the literature

 

Congruence between preferred and perceived participation %

Preferences in participation %

 

Yes preferred and perceived participation were equal

No, preferred more participation

No, preferred less participation

Active

Shared

Passive

Ramfelt et al., 2005 Sweden [33]

31

55

14

18

47

35

Caress, 1997 UK [34]

36

54

10

49

31

16

Sepucha et al., 2009 USA [22]

38

46

16

8

88

4

Hack et al., 2006 Canada [35]

48

41

12

36

42

23

Kremer et al., 2007 USA [36]

49

25

25

28

59

13

Bilodeau et al., 1996 Canada [37]*

50

-

-

20

37

43

Caress et al., 2005 UK

51

43

6

24

36

40

Beaver and Booth, 1999 UK [38]

      

Colorectal cancer

52

33

16

4

17

78

Breast cancer

60

22

18

20

28

52

Purbrick et al., 2006 UK [39]

56

18

26

10

69

21

Carey et al., 2012 Australia [40]

56

34

10

26

30

45

Jefford et al., 2011 Australia [41]

57

27

12

29

37

30

Nakashima et al., 2012 Japan [42]

59

24

16

18

69

13

Ford et al., 2003 UK [43]

60

25

15

18

46

36

Caldon, 2008 UK [44]

61

9

29

40

42

17

Krist et al., 2007 USA [45]**

      

Control group

61

23

16

-

-

-

Brochure group

69

21

10

-

-

-

Website group

73

16

11

-

-

-

Vogel et al., 2008 Germany [46]

63

22

15

31

29

40

Wallberg et al., 2009 Sweden [47]

66

27

7

10

68

23

Beaver et al., 2007 UK [48]*

      

Gyneacolocal cancer

66

23

11

21

32

47

Breast cancer

39

-

-

15

24

61

Colorectal cancer

61

-

-

7

13

80

Hawley et al., 2007 USA [49]**

66

13

21

-

-

-

Zhang et al., 2011 China [50]

69

28

3

11

46

44

Mahone, 2008 USA [19]*

69

-

-

11

82

17

Lantz et al., 2005 USA [51]**

69

11

20

-

-

-

Murray et al., 2007 UK [20]

71

17

12

28

62

9

Pardon et al., 2011 Belgium [52]

71

20

9

15

22

63

Davidson et al., 1999 Canada [53]

71

29

0

19

24

57

Wallberg et al., 2000 Sweden [54]

72

20

8

13

21

66

Joliceur et al., 2009 Canada [55]

77

23

0

15

54

31

Lam et al., 2003 China [18]

80

7

13

33

59

8

Mohamedali et al., 2010 Canada [56]*

80

-

-

11

52

37

Vogel et al., 2009 Germany [57]**

84

2

15

-

-

-

Hawley et al., 2008 USA [58]**

93

4

3

-

-

-

Palmer et al., 2012 USA [21]

97

3

1

45

39

16

Total

Mean

63

24

13

21

43

36

Percentiles 25 - 75

54-71

16-29

8-16

11-28

29-59

17-48

  1. Preference retrospectively measured (n = 32 studies, n = 37 patient samples).
  2. Note *: Studies reported% of congruence, but not% for direction of mismatch.
  3. Note **: Studies reported perceived participation.
  4. Table sorted on% congruence.