Skip to main content

Table 16 Wilcoxon signed-rank test: Classifiers with feature subset versus Classifiers with 10 features on Hungarian dataset

From: A hybrid cost-sensitive ensemble for heart disease prediction

 

RF

LR

SVM

ELM

KNN

Ensemble

E

   Z-value\(^{1}\)

− 2.803

− 2.803

− 2.803

− 2.803

− 2.497

− 2.701

   p value\(^{2}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.010^{*}\)

\(0.004^{**}\)

Precision

   Z-value

− 2.293

− 2.497

− 1,478

− 2.497

− 1.886

− 2.701

   p value

\(0.020^{*}\)

\(0.010^{*}\)

0.160

\(0.010^{*}\)

0.065

\(0.004^{**}\)

Recall

   Z-value

− 1.886

− 2.497

− 2.395

− 1.376

− 2.497

− 1.886

   p value

0.065

\(0.010^{*}\)

\(0.014^{*}\)

0.193

\(0.010^{*}\)

0.065

G-mean

   Z-value

− 2.191

− 2.803

− 2.497

− 2.803

− 1.580

− 2.599

   p value

\(0.027^{*}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.010^{*}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

0.131

\(0.006^{**}\)

MC

   Z-value

− 2.090

− 2.803

− 2.599

− 2.599

− 2.497

− 2.191

   p value

\(0.037^{*}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.006^{**}\)

\(0.006^{**}\)

\(0.010^{*}\)

\(0.027^{*}\)

Specificity

   Z-value

− 2.599

− 2.497

− 1.886

− 2.803

− 1.988

− 2.803

   p value

\(0.006^{**}\)

\(0.010^{*}\)

0.065

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.049^{*}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

AUC

   Z-value

− 2.599

− 2.803

− 2.803

− 2.701

− 2.701

− 2.803

   p value

\(0.006^{**}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

\(0.004^{**}\)

\(0.004^{**}\)

\(0.002^{**}\)

  1. \(^1\) The value of Wilcoxon statistics after standardization
  2. \(^2\) \(^*\) \(p < 0.05\), \(^{**}\) \(p < 0.01\)