Definitions, components and processes of data harmonisation in healthcare: a scoping review

Schmidt, Bey-Marrié; Colvin, Christopher J.; Hohlfeld, Ameer; Leon, Natalie

doi:10.1186/s12911-020-01218-7

BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making

Table 2 Characteristics of sampled studies (n = 61)

From: Definitions, components and processes of data harmonisation in healthcare: a scoping review

Study name	Date	Type of study	Intervention term	Country	Level of the health care system	Purpose of the study
Akhlaq	2016	Review, qualitative	HIE	LMICs	Management, countries	Barriers and facilitators of HIE
Boyd Boyd	2014	Conceptual	RL	Australia	Research	Functions of record linkage
Burris	2017	Commentary	HIE	USA	Frontline: hospitals	Benefits of HIE
Campion	2012	Primary, quantitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: health care workers	Push and pull of HIE
Cimino	2014	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Debates around consumer-mediated HIE
Dalan	2010	Conceptual	DM	USA	Management	Possibilities for clinical data mining and research
Dimitropoulos	2009	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Privacy and security of interoperable HIE
Dixon	2010	Review, framework	HIE	USA	Research	Costs, effort and value of HIE
Downing	2017	Primary, quantitative	HIE	USA	Management: policy	Relationship between HIE and organisational HIE policy decisions
Downs	2010	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Improving laboratory services through HIE
Dullabh	2013	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Management: organisations	Experience of HIE implementation
Elysee Elysee	2017	Primary, quantitative	HIE, IO	USA	Frontline: hospitals	Relationship between HIE, interoperability and medication reconciliation
Esmaeilzadeh	2016	Review	HIE	n/a	Management: policy	HIE assimilation and patterns for policy
Esmaeilzadeh	2017	Review	HIE	n/a	Frontline: patients	Patients’ perceptions of HIE
Fontaine	2010	Review	HIE	n/a	Frontline: primary health care	HIE for primary health care practices
Fontaine	2010	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: primary health care	Barriers and facilitators of HIE in primary care practices
Frisse	2010	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Frontline: patients, workers	Impact of HIE on patient-provider relationships
Gadd	2011	Primary, quantitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: health care workers	Users’ perspectives on the usability of a regional HIE
Gill	2001	Primary, quantitative	DL	South Africa	Frontline: patients, disease	Linkage of non-communicable diseases data
Greene	2016	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Technical and financial aspects of HIE
Grossman	2008	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Barriers to stakeholder participation in HIE
Haarbrandt	2016	Conceptual	DW	USA	Management	Approaches for a clinical data warehouse
Herwehe	2012	Primary, quantitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: health care workers	Implementation of an electronic medical record and HIE
Hincapie	2011	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: health care workers	Physicians’ opinions of HIE
Hopf	2014	Review	DL	n/a	Frontline: health care workers	Healthcare professionals’ views of linking routinely collected data
Hu	2007	Conceptual	DS	USA	Management	Challenges in implementing an infectious disease information sharing and analysis system
Hypponen	2014	Primary, quantitative	HIE	Finland	Frontline: health care workers	User experiences with different regional HIE
Ji	2017	Primary, quantitative	HIE	Korea	Frontline: hospitals	Technology and policy changes for HIE
Jones	2012	Conceptual	DS	USA	Management	An overview of electronic data sharing
Kash	2017	Review	HIE	n/a	Frontline: hospitals	Hospital readmission reduction and the role of HIE
Kierkegaard	2014	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: health care workers	Applications of HIE information to public health practice
Kierkegaard	2014	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Management	Health practitioners’ needs and HIE
Kuperman	2013	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Potential unintended consequences of HIE
Liu	2010	Primary, qualitative	DH	China	Management	Defining data elements for HIE
Maiorana	2012	Primary, mixed	HIE	USA	Frontline: workers, disease	Trust, confidentiality and acceptability of sharing HIV data for HIE
Massoudi	2016	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: organisations	HIE for clinical quality measures
Mastebroek	2014	Review	HIE	USA	Frontline: disease, workers	HIE in general care practice for people with disabilities
Mastebroek	2016	Primary, quantitative	HIE	Netherlands	Frontline: health care workers	Priority setting and feasibility of HIE
Mastebroek	2017	Primary, qualitative	HIE	Netherlands	Frontline: patients	Experiences of people with intellectual disabilities in HIE
Matsumoto	2017	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: workers, hospitals	HIE in managing hospital services
Parker	2016	Review	HIE	USA	Research	The use of HIE in supporting clinical research
Politi	2014	Conceptual	HIE	n/a	Management	Use patterns of HIE
Rahurkar	2015	Review	HIE	n/a	Frontline: hospital	Impact of HIE on cost, use and quality of care
Ramos	2016	Primary, mixed	HIE	USA	Frontline: patients	HIE consent process in an HIV clinic
Ranade-Kharkar	2014	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Improving data quality integrity through HIE
Ross	2010	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: clinics	Motivators, barriers, and potential facilitators of adoption of HIE
Rudin	2014	Review	HIE	USA	Frontline: clinical care	Use and effect of HIE on clinical care
Vest	2016	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Management: policy makers, leaders	Information-sharing needs and HIE
Sadoughi	2018	Review	HIE	n/a	Management	Quality and cost-effectiveness, and the rates of HIE adoption and participation
Santos	2017	Primary, quantitative	HIE	Brazil	Frontline: clinics, hospitals	HIE for continuity of maternal and neonatal care
Shade	2012	Primary, quantitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: clinics, hospitals	HIE for quality and continuity of HIV care
Shapiro	2016	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Frontline: workers, organisations	HIE in emergency medicine
Shapiro	2006	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Approaches to patient HIE and their impact on emergency medicine
Vest	2012	Review	HIE	n/a	Management	National and international approaches of health information exchange
Vest	2015	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: consumers, organisations	HIE to change cost and utilisation outcomes
Vest	2010	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Challenges and strategies for HIE
Williams	2012	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Strategies to advance HIE
Yaraghi	2014	Conceptual	HIE	USA	Management	Professional and geographical network effects on HIE growth
Yeager	2014	Primary, qualitative	HIE	USA	Frontline: consumers	Factors related to HIE participation and use
Zaidan	2015	Conceptual	HIE	Malaysia	Management	Security framework for nationwide HIE
Zhu	2010	Primary quantitative	HIE	USA	Research	Facilitating clinical research through HIE

Back to article page

ISSN: 1472-6947

Contact us

General enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com