Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of main features of included studies

From: Multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) in health care: a systematic review of the main characteristics and methodological steps

Author

Journal

Country

Intervention type

Problem type

Problem definition

Definition of criteria

Method

Tarimcilar and Khaksari [50]

Socioecon. Plann. Sci.

USA

Management

Ranking

Decision-makers

Decision-makers

AHP

Sinuany-stern et al. [64]

Locat. Sci.

Israel

Management

Choice

Group discussion

Group discussion

AHP

Dolan [48]

Heal. Expect.

USA

Health Care

Choice

Group discussion and specialists

Literature

AHP

Baltussen and Niessen [21]

Cost Eff. Resour. Alloc.

Netherlands

Resources

Sorting

Decision-makers

Decision-makers

WHO-CHOICE

Singh et al. [33]

BMC Med. Inform. Decis. Mak.

USA

Management

Sorting

Decision-makers

Decision-makers

AHP

Ágnes [66]

Magy. Onkol.

Hungary

Resources

Ranking

Literature

Literature

FUZZY LOGIC

Doerner et al. [27]

Eur. J. Oper. Res.

Senegal

Location

Choice

Literature

Literature

P-ACO

Goetghebeur et al. [25]

BMC Health Serv. Res.

Canada

Management

Sorting

Literature

Literature

EVIDEM

Jehu-appiah et al. [61]

Value Heal.

Ghana

Health Care

Ranking

Decision-makers

Interview

WHO-CHOICE

Kuzma et al. [49]

Risk Anal.

USA

Management

Sorting

Literature

Group discussion

IOA

Sustersic et al. [32]

J Int Med Res

Slovenia

Health Care

Sorting

Specialists

Literature

HMADM

Dursun et al. [31]

World Acad. Sci. Eng. Technol.

Turkey

Pollution

Ranking

Group discussion and specialists

Group discussion

FUZZY LOGIC

Goetghebeur et al. [39]

Cost Eff. Resour. Alloc.

Canada

Health Care

Sorting

Literature

specialists

EVIDEM

Danner et al. [67]

Int. J. Technol. Assess. Health Care

Germany

Health Care

Ranking

Decision-makers

Group discussion

AHP

Dursun et al. [42]

World Acad. Sci. Eng. Technol.

Turkey

Pollution

Ranking

Group discussion and specialists

Literature

FUZZY LOGIC

Dursun et al. [43]

Resour. Conserv. Recycl.

Turkey

Pollution

Choice

Literature and specialists

Literature and specialists

FUZZY LOGIC

Lee and Kwak [68]

J. Med. Syst.

South Korea

Management

Ranking

Group discussion

Group discussion

AHP

Padma and Balasubramanie [35]

Expert Syst. Appl.

India

Health Care

Ranking

Specialists

Literature

FUZZY LOGIC

Tony et al. [40]

BMC Health Serv. Res.

Canada

Health Care

Choice

Decision-makers

Literature

EVIDEM

Defechereux et al. [62]

BMC Health Serv. Res.

Norway

Others

Sorting

Literature

Specialists

FUZZY LOGIC

Mirelman et al. [63]

Value Heal.

Brazil, Nepal, Norway, Uganda and Cuba

Others

Ranking

Literature

Specialists

FUZZY LOGIC

Hummel et al. [56]

Appl. Health Econ. Health Policy

Netherlands

Health Care

Choice

Decision-makers

Literature

AHP

Isoke and Van Dijk [69]

Water Environ. J.

Uganda

Pollution

Sorting

specialists

specialists

AHP

Liu et al. [10]

Waste Manag.

China

Pollution

Ranking

Literature

Specialists

VIKOR

Lu et al. [26]

Decis. Support Syst.

Taiwan

Resources

Choice

specialists

Literature

VIKOR

Özkan [45]

Waste Manag. Res.

Turkey

Pollution

Ranking

Literature

Literature

ANP and ELECTRE III

Diaz-Ledezma et al. [47]

Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.

USA

Health Care

Ranking

Literature

Literature

AHP

Liu et al. [51]

Waste Manag.

China

Pollution

Choice

Literature

Specialists

ITL-MULTIMOORA

Oddershede et al. [70]

Int. J. Comput. Commun. Control

Chile

Resources

Ranking

Decision-makers

Literature

OPENET

Reddy et al. [34]

Public Health

United Kingdom

Health Care

Ranking

Group discussion and specialists

Group discussion

AHP

Stromme et al. [71]

Dev. World Bioeth.

Norway

Health Care

Ranking

Literature

Literature

FUZZY LOGIC

Til et al. [57]

Cost Eff. Resour. Alloc.

Netherlands

Resources

Ranking

Literature

Specialists

EVIDEM

Venhorst et al. [58]

Cost Eff. Resour. Alloc.

Netherlands

Health Care

Sorting

Group discussion

Specialists

DELPHI

Ahmadi et al. [65]

Int. J. Med. Inform.

Malaysia

Resources

Sorting

Literature

Specialists

ANP

Cabrera-Barona et al. [72]

IInt. J. Health Geogr.

Ecuador

Others

Sorting

Literature

Literature

AHP

Dehe and Bamford [9]

Expert Syst. Appl.

United Kingdom

Location

Choice

Literature

Decision-makers

AHP

Diaby and Lachaine [38]

Appl. Health Econ. Health Policy

Canada

Management

Ranking

Decision-makers

Decision-makers

WHO

Graaf et al. [55]

Biomed Res. Int.

Netherlands

Health Care

Ranking

Group discussion and specialists

Group discussion and literature

SMAA-O

Kulak et al. [44]

Appl. Soft Comput.

Turkey

Resources

Choice

Group discussion

Group discussion

FUZZY LOGIC

Kuruoglu et al. [73]

BMC Med. Inform. Decis. Mak.

Peru

Others

Choice

Group discussion

Literature and specialists

AHP

Paolucci et al. [53]

Health Policy Plan.

China

Health Care

Ranking

Decision-makers

Decision-makers

DCE

Ritrovato et al. [74]

Value in Health

Italy

Health Care

Choice

Literature

Literature

AHP

Wahlster et al. [75]

Heal. Res. Policy Syst.

Germany

Others

Sorting

Literature

Specialists

EVIDEM

Carnero [30]

Shock Vib.

Portugal

Resources

Choice

Literature

Literature

FAHP

Carnero and Gómez [76]

BMC Med. Inform. Decis. Mak.

Spain

Resources

Choice

Literature

Group discussion and literature

MACBETH

Delice and Zegerek [8]

Appl. Math. Inf. Sci.

Turkey

Turkey

Ranking

Ranking

Specialists

FUZZY LOGIC- GRA

Diaby et al. [46]

Expert Rev. Pharmacoecon. Outcomes Res.

USA

Resources

Choice

Group discussion

Group discussion

ELICIT

Gómez and Carnero [77]

Int. Fed. Autom. Control

Portugal

Resources

Choice

Literature

Group discussion

MACBETH

Hongoh et al. [29]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health

Canada

Health Care

Ranking

Group discussion and decision-makers

Group discussion and literature

PROMETHEE II

Hussain and Malik [36]

J. Health Organ. Manag.

Abu Dhabi

Pollution

Ranking

Literature

Literature

AHP

Hussain et al. [78]

Bus. Process Manag. J.

United Arab Emirates

Health Care

Choice

Specialists

Literature and specialists

AHP

Kalhor et al. [79]

J. Biol. Today’s World

Iran

Pollution

Choice

Specialists

Specialists

TOPSIS

Kim and Kim [80]

Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang.

Korea

Health Care

Ranking

Specialists

Specialists

AHP

Lu et al. [52]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health

China

Pollution

Choice

Literature

Specialists

ITI-TOPSIS

Mahfoud et al. [81]

Am. J. Appl. Sci.

Morocco

Resources

Ranking

Specialists

Specialists

PROMETHEE

Merola et al. [82]

Int. J. Bus. Syst. Res.

Italy

Resources

Ranking

Group discussion and literature

Literature

AHP

Mohamadi et al. [83]

Shiraz E-Med J

Iran

Health Care

Choice

Literature and specialists

Group discussion and literature

SAW

Nilashi et al. [84]

Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang.

Malaysia

Resources

Sorting

Literature

Literature

ANP

Rebolledo et al. [59]

J. Environ. Manage.

Spain

Pollution

Sorting

Literature

Literature

AHP

Shafii et al. [85]

Osong Public Heal. Res. Perspect.

Iran

Others l

Ranking

Literature

Literature

TOPSIS

Wagner et al. [41]

PharmacoEconomics

Canada

Health Care

Ranking

Decision-makers

Literature

EVIDEM

Wang et al. [54]

Comput. Ind. Eng.

China

Others

Ranking

Group discussion and decision-makers

Literature and specialists

IVIF-COPRAS

Carnero and Gómez [28]

Sustain.

Spain

Resources

Choice

Literature

Group discussion

MACBETH

Hancerliogullari et al. [86]

BMC Med. Inform. Decis. Mak.

United Kingdom

Resources

Ranking

Decision-makers

Specialists

TOPSIS

Hillerman et al. [87]

J. Comput. Sci.

Brazil

Management

Ranking

Group discussion and literature

Literature

AHP

Hillerman et al. [87]

J. Comput. Sci.

Brazil

Management

Ranking

Group discussion and literature

Literature

AHP

Wagner et al. [60]

BMC Cancer

France, Italy and Spain

Health Care

Ranking

Literature

Literature

FUZZY LOGIC