Skip to main content

Table 2 Changes in knowledge and intent to initiate lung cancer screening before and after viewing the decision aid (n = 50)

From: A pre-post study testing a lung cancer screening decision aid in primary care

 

Pre

Post

Difference (95% CI), p-value

Potential Harms of Screening

 Who do you think is more likely to be diagnosed with lung cancer?

People who are screened for lung cancer.a

People who are NOT screened for lung cancer

36%

62%

26% (8%, 44%), p < 0.001

 ALL lung cancers will eventually cause illness and death if they are not found and treated.

True/Falsea/Don’t Know

6%

54%

48% (31%, 65%), p < 0.001

 When screening finds lung cancer, doctors can tell whether the cancer will ever cause harm.

True/Falsea/Don’t Know

16%

62%

46% (62%, 30%), p < 0.001

 Even lung cancers that may not cause any health problems are likely to be treated.

Truea/False/Don’t Know

66%

80%

14% (4%, 32%), p = 0.09

 Screening tests lead some people to get cancer treatments that they do not need.

Truea/False/Don’t Know

18%

76%

58% (40%, 76%), p < 0.001

 Screening tests find harmless lung cancers about as often as they prevent death from lung cancer.

Truea/False/Don’t Know

24%

52%

28% (9%, 47%), p < 0.001

 Which of these 2 statements best describes over-detection from screening?

Screening finds a cancer that would never have caused troublea

Screening finds an abnormality but extra tests show it is not cancer

16%

28%

12% (3%, 27%), p = 0.08

 An abnormal result from lung cancer screening always means the person has lung cancer.

True/Falsea/Don’t Know

66%

88%

22% (5%, 39%), p < 0.001

Chances of Benefitting from Screening

 For the next question, please think about 1000 current and former smokers who are getting screened every year for lung cancer. Out of 1000 people who get a chest CT scan, about how many will have their lives prolonged?

0

1-5a

6-10a

11-30a

31–100

101–200

201–400

401–700

701–1000

Don’t Know

18%

48%

30% (12%, 48%), p < 0.001

Average Knowledge Score (0–9 points)

2.6

5.5

2.8 (2.1,3.6), p < 0.001

  1. aCorrect response(s)