Table 2 Demographics of included studies
From: A systematic review of the implementation and impact of asthma protocols
Ref | Author | Year | Reminder type | Setting | Study Design | Randomized | Patient Population | Clinician Population | Setting | Centers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[30] | Abisheganaden J | 2001 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | IN | Single |
[31] | Abisheganaden J | 1998 | Pa | Other | Descrip | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[32] | Ables A | 2002 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Single |
[33] | Akerman M | 1999 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[24] | Alamoudi O | 2002 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Single |
[34] | Baddar S | 2006 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[35] | Bailey R | 1998 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | IN | Single |
[36] | Baker R | 2003 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[37] | Bell LM | 2010 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | PED | MD, RN | OUT | Multi |
[38] | Boskabady MH | 2008 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | O | OUT | Single |
[39] | Callahan C | 2003 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | MD | OUT | Single |
[40] | Cerci Neto AC | 2008 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | Adult, PED | MD, RN | IN | Multi |
[41] | Chamnan | 2010 | Pa | nonAcad | Other | 0 | Adult | O | Out | Single |
[42] | Chan D | 2007 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | PED | O | OUT | Single |
[43] | Chee C | 1996 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | IN | Single |
[44] | Cho SH | 2010 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[45] | Chouaid C | 2004 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[46] | Cloutier M | 2006 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 1 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[47] | Cloutier M | 2005 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[48] | Colice G | 2005 | CG | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | RT | IN | Single |
[49] | Cunningham S | 2008 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 1 | PED | O | ED | Single |
[50] | Dalcin P | 2007 | CG | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[51] | Davies B | 2008 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult | RN | OUT, ED | Multi |
[52] | Davis AM | 2010 | CP | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Single |
Doherty S | 2007 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Multi | |
[53] | Duke T | 1991 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | MD | ED | Single |
[54] | Eccles M | 2002 | CG | nonAcad | Retro | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[55] | Emond S | 1999 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[56] | Feder G | 1995 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | Adult | O | OUT | Multi |
[57] | Fifield J | 2010 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | PED | O | OUT | Multi |
[58] | Gentile N | 2003 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[59] | Gibson P | 1996 | Pa | nonAcad | Descrip | 0 | Adult | MD | IN | Single |
[60] | Gildenhuys J | 2009 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | O | ED | Single |
[61] | Goh AEN | 2010 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | PED | O | IN, ED | Single |
[62] | Goldberg R | 1998 | Pa | Other | Pro | 0 | Adult | RN | OUT | Single |
[63] | Guarnaccia S | 2007 | Pa | Acad | Descrip | 0 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[64] | Hagmolen of ten Have W | 2008 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[65] | Halterman JS | 2006 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 1 | PED | O | OUT | Multi |
[66] | Heaney L | 2003 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[67] | Jans M | 2001 | Pa | nonAcad | Descrip | 0 | PED | O | OUT | Multi |
[68] | Jans MP | 1998 | Pa | nonAcad | Descrip | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[69] | Joe R | 1992 | Pa | Acad | Descrip | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[70] | Johnson K | 2000 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 1 | PED | RN | IN | Single |
[71] | Jones CA | 2007 | Pa | Acad | Other | 0 | PED | O | OUT, Other | Multi |
[72] | Kelly A | 2007 | Other | nonAcad | Descrip | 0 | Adult, PED | O | ED | Multi |
[73] | Kelly C | 2000 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 1 | PED | MD | IN | Single |
[7] | Kuilboer M | 2006 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[74] | Kwan-Gett T | 1997 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | RN | IN | Single |
[75] | Kwok R | 2009 | CP | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[76] | Lehman HK | 2006 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[77] | Lesho E | 2005 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[78] | Lierl M | 1999 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | PED | RT | IN | Single |
[79] | Lim T | 2000 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | IN | Single |
[80] | Lougheed MD | 2009 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Multi |
[81] | Lukacs S | 2002 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | O | OUT | Multi |
[82] | Maa SA | 2010 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | PED | O | Other | Single |
[83] | Mackey D | 2007 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[84] | Martens JD | 2007 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | None | MD | OUT | Multi |
[85] | Martin E | 2001 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[86] | Massie J | 2004 | Pa | Acad | Descrip | 0 | PED | O | ED | Single |
[87] | Mccowan C | 2001 | CP | nonAcad | Descrip | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[88] | McDowell K | 1998 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | MD | IN | Single |
[89] | McFadden E | 1995 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[90] | Mitchell E | 2005 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[91] | Nelson K | 2009 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | RN | Other | Single |
[92] | Newcomb P | 2006 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | RN | OUT | Single |
[93] | Norton S | 2007 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | MD | ED | Single |
[94] | Patel P | 2004 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[95] | Porter S | 2006 | CG | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | MD | ED | Single |
[96] | Press S | 1991 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | O | ED | Single |
[97] | Qazi K | 2010 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | PED | RN | ED | Single |
[98] | Quint DM | 2009 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 1 | PED | O | ED | Single |
[99] | Renzi P | 2006 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[100] | Robinson S | 1996 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[101] | Rowe BH | 2008 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD, RT | ED | Single |
[102] | Ruoff G | 2002 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Single |
[103] | Schneider A | 2008 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |
[104] | Schneider S | 1986 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[105] | Shelledy D | 2005 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | RT | IN | Single |
[106] | Sherman J | 1997 | Pa | Acad | Descrip | 0 | PED | MD | Other | Multi |
[9] | Shiffman R | 2000 | CP | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[107] | Stead L | 1999 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | O | ED | Single |
[108] | Stell I | 1996 | Pa | nonAcad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[109] | Steurer-Stey C | 2005 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[110] | Stormon M | 1999 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 1 | PED | O | IN | Single |
[111] | Sucov A | 2000 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[112] | Suh D | 2001 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | IN | Single |
[113] | Sulaiman NB | 2010 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | PED | MD | OUT | Multi |
[114] | Suzuki T | 2010 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Single |
[115] | Szilagyi P | 1992 | CP | Acad | Pro | 1 | PED | MD | OUT | Single |
[116] | Thomas K | 1999 | CG | Other | Descrip | 1 | PED | MD | Other | Single |
[117] | Tierney W | 2005 | CG | Acad | Pro | 1 | Adult | O | OUT | Single |
To T | 2008 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult, PED | O | OUT | Multi | |
[118] | Touzin K | 2008 | Pa | Acad | Retro, Descrip | 0 | PED | MD | ED | Single |
[119] | Town I | 1990 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | Adult | MD | ED | Single |
[120] | van de Meer V | 2010 | Other | nonAcad | Pro | 1 | Adult | O | OUT | Multi |
[121] | Vandeleur M | 2009 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | MD, RN | IN | Single |
[122] | Wazeka A | 2001 | Pa | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | O | IN | Single |
[123] | Webb L | 1992 | Pa | Acad | Pro | 0 | PED | O | IN | Single |
[124] | Welsh K | 1999 | CG | Acad | Retro | 0 | PED | MD | IN | Single |
[125] | Wright J | 2003 | Pa | nonAcad | Pro | 0 | Adult | MD | OUT | Multi |