Skip to main content

Table 2 Demographics of included studies

From: A systematic review of the implementation and impact of asthma protocols

Ref Author Year Reminder type Setting Study Design Randomized Patient Population Clinician Population Setting Centers
[30] Abisheganaden J 2001 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD IN Single
[31] Abisheganaden J 1998 Pa Other Descrip 0 Adult O ED Single
[32] Ables A 2002 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Single
[33] Akerman M 1999 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[24] Alamoudi O 2002 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Single
[34] Baddar S 2006 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
[35] Bailey R 1998 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD IN Single
[36] Baker R 2003 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 Adult MD OUT Multi
[37] Bell LM 2010 CP nonAcad Pro 1 PED MD, RN OUT Multi
[38] Boskabady MH 2008 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult O OUT Single
[39] Callahan C 2003 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED MD OUT Single
[40] Cerci Neto AC 2008 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 Adult, PED MD, RN IN Multi
[41] Chamnan 2010 Pa nonAcad Other 0 Adult O Out Single
[42] Chan D 2007 CP nonAcad Pro 1 PED O OUT Single
[43] Chee C 1996 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 Adult O IN Single
[44] Cho SH 2010 CP nonAcad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
[45] Chouaid C 2004 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult O ED Single
[46] Cloutier M 2006 Pa nonAcad Retro 1 PED MD OUT Multi
[47] Cloutier M 2005 Pa Acad Retro 0 PED MD OUT Multi
[48] Colice G 2005 CG Acad Pro 0 Adult RT IN Single
[49] Cunningham S 2008 Pa Acad Pro 1 PED O ED Single
[50] Dalcin P 2007 CG Acad Pro 0 Adult O ED Single
[51] Davies B 2008 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 Adult RN OUT, ED Multi
[52] Davis AM 2010 CP Acad Retro 0 Adult MD OUT Single
[2527] Doherty S 2007 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 Adult O ED Multi
[53] Duke T 1991 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED MD ED Single
[54] Eccles M 2002 CG nonAcad Retro 1 Adult MD OUT Multi
[55] Emond S 1999 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult O ED Single
[56] Feder G 1995 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 Adult O OUT Multi
[57] Fifield J 2010 CP nonAcad Pro 0 PED O OUT Multi
[58] Gentile N 2003 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[59] Gibson P 1996 Pa nonAcad Descrip 0 Adult MD IN Single
[60] Gildenhuys J 2009 Pa Acad Retro 0 PED O ED Single
[61] Goh AEN 2010 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 PED O IN, ED Single
[62] Goldberg R 1998 Pa Other Pro 0 Adult RN OUT Single
[63] Guarnaccia S 2007 Pa Acad Descrip 0 PED MD OUT Multi
[64] Hagmolen of ten Have W 2008 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 PED MD OUT Multi
[65] Halterman JS 2006 Pa Acad Pro 1 PED O OUT Multi
[66] Heaney L 2003 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
[67] Jans M 2001 Pa nonAcad Descrip 0 PED O OUT Multi
[68] Jans MP 1998 Pa nonAcad Descrip 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
[69] Joe R 1992 Pa Acad Descrip 0 Adult MD ED Single
[70] Johnson K 2000 Pa Acad Pro 1 PED RN IN Single
[71] Jones CA 2007 Pa Acad Other 0 PED O OUT, Other Multi
[72] Kelly A 2007 Other nonAcad Descrip 0 Adult, PED O ED Multi
[73] Kelly C 2000 Pa Acad Retro 1 PED MD IN Single
[7] Kuilboer M 2006 CP nonAcad Pro 1 Adult MD OUT Multi
[74] Kwan-Gett T 1997 Pa Acad Retro 0 PED RN IN Single
[75] Kwok R 2009 CP nonAcad Retro 0 Adult O ED Single
[76] Lehman HK 2006 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 PED MD OUT Multi
[77] Lesho E 2005 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
[78] Lierl M 1999 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 PED RT IN Single
[79] Lim T 2000 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD IN Single
[80] Lougheed MD 2009 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult O ED Multi
[81] Lukacs S 2002 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED O OUT Multi
[82] Maa SA 2010 CP nonAcad Pro 0 PED O Other Single
[83] Mackey D 2007 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[84] Martens JD 2007 CP nonAcad Pro 1 None MD OUT Multi
[85] Martin E 2001 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 PED MD OUT Multi
[86] Massie J 2004 Pa Acad Descrip 0 PED O ED Single
[87] Mccowan C 2001 CP nonAcad Descrip 1 Adult MD OUT Multi
[88] McDowell K 1998 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED MD IN Single
[89] McFadden E 1995 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[90] Mitchell E 2005 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 PED MD OUT Multi
[91] Nelson K 2009 Pa Acad Retro 0 PED RN Other Single
[92] Newcomb P 2006 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED RN OUT Single
[93] Norton S 2007 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED MD ED Single
[94] Patel P 2004 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
[95] Porter S 2006 CG Acad Pro 0 PED MD ED Single
[96] Press S 1991 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED O ED Single
[97] Qazi K 2010 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 PED RN ED Single
[98] Quint DM 2009 Pa Acad Pro 1 PED O ED Single
[99] Renzi P 2006 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 Adult MD OUT Multi
[100] Robinson S 1996 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult O ED Single
[101] Rowe BH 2008 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD, RT ED Single
[102] Ruoff G 2002 Pa nonAcad Retro 1 Adult MD OUT Single
[103] Schneider A 2008 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 Adult MD OUT Multi
[104] Schneider S 1986 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[105] Shelledy D 2005 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED RT IN Single
[106] Sherman J 1997 Pa Acad Descrip 0 PED MD Other Multi
[9] Shiffman R 2000 CP nonAcad Pro 1 PED MD OUT Multi
[107] Stead L 1999 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult O ED Single
[108] Stell I 1996 Pa nonAcad Retro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[109] Steurer-Stey C 2005 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[110] Stormon M 1999 Pa Acad Pro 1 PED O IN Single
[111] Sucov A 2000 Pa Acad Pro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[112] Suh D 2001 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD IN Single
[113] Sulaiman NB 2010 Pa nonAcad Pro 1 PED MD OUT Multi
[114] Suzuki T 2010 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD OUT Single
[115] Szilagyi P 1992 CP Acad Pro 1 PED MD OUT Single
[116] Thomas K 1999 CG Other Descrip 1 PED MD Other Single
[117] Tierney W 2005 CG Acad Pro 1 Adult O OUT Single
[28, 29] To T 2008 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 Adult, PED O OUT Multi
[118] Touzin K 2008 Pa Acad Retro, Descrip 0 PED MD ED Single
[119] Town I 1990 Pa Acad Retro 0 Adult MD ED Single
[120] van de Meer V 2010 Other nonAcad Pro 1 Adult O OUT Multi
[121] Vandeleur M 2009 Pa Acad Retro 0 PED MD, RN IN Single
[122] Wazeka A 2001 Pa Acad Retro 0 PED O IN Single
[123] Webb L 1992 Pa Acad Pro 0 PED O IN Single
[124] Welsh K 1999 CG Acad Retro 0 PED MD IN Single
[125] Wright J 2003 Pa nonAcad Pro 0 Adult MD OUT Multi
  1. Table 1 key: CG – computer generated, Pa – paper-based, CP – computerized. Acad –academic setting, nonAcad – non academic setting, Pro – prospective, Retro – retrospective, Descrip – Descriptive, PED – pediatric, O – other, MD – physician, RN – nurse, RT – respiratory therapist, IN inpatient, OUT – outpatient, ED – emergency department, Multi – multi-center trial.